Bosworth 1485

by on November 12, 2012 at 10:40 pm
Posted In: Books, History

As usual, Osprey’s Campaign series does an excellent job of presenting the background and people involved in the battle in question. In this case, the later stages of the Wars of the Roses, and Richard III’s reign are covered very well. There is a lot that cannot be known through the distorting lens of Tudor propaganda, but some good points are made.

The general course of Henry Tudor’s landing and march into central England are handled well (I like the Campaign series in general because it is as much about the maneuvering to battle as much as the battle itself), with the usual excellent maps. There are also several very nice two-page spread original color paintings by Graham Turner scattered throughout, instead of art borrowed from previous books. There are two problems here: One, they usually have a paragraph or so of the main text over part of the art, and the contrast is often low enough to make reading the text difficult. Two, the people, even when they are supposed to be in motion, look posed. Other than that, they’re fine pieces, but my eyes are trained by an artist also educated as an animator; these people don’t look like they’re moving.

A final problem is that the book was published in 1999, and a couple surveys conducted since then indicate the battle may have been fought about two miles from where it was previously believed to be. It is still worth picking up, especially if found cheap, but I hope that once the resulting arguments start working their way through academia, Osprey will release a new edition of the volume.

└ Tags: , , , , ,
1 Comment

A38 North Bank

by on November 8, 2012 at 12:00 pm
Posted In: ASL

Patch and I finally finished up our tour of the A’91 Market Garden scenarios in December 2009…:

Last week me and Patch started the last of the Market-Garden scenarios from Annual ’91. Thankfully, we have the errata from FKaC, since it’s not very balanced in the original.

I’m playing the Germans, who are trying to drive the British away from their remaining foothold near the Arnhem bridge, and the river. I have 7 SS squads, good leadership, two Tiger IIs, and seven turns. The Brits have 4 squads, better leadership, a Hero, a 57mm ATG, and Ammunition shortage. Oh, and thanks to the errata, 8 OB-given ‘?’ (and I enter on turn one, so everyone else gets freebies), and I don’t know who has his 3 PIATs until he uses them. Four AT weapons, none of which can penetrate the front armor, but since I don’t know where they are, a back, or at least flank, shot is probably going to come up sooner or later. At least I know the PIATs can’t be where he isn’t.

Patch set up a loose perimeter at the north edge, with a couple of high observation posts. Not liking the open west terrain for entry, I went for the east half with the hopes of driving a wedge into the 21U6 building area. The Brit 10-3 turned out to be in one of the high posts (of course) and managed to break my 9-2 and a squad shortly after entry, also pinning a second squad. Naturally, the Brit 9-2 was in the other high location (which my eyes seem to have skipped over), who then pinned the 7-0 and a squad.

Thankfully, that was all the mischief he was able to accomplish, while I got a lucky PTC on 21Z8, and revealed it to be dummies.


Situation, German Turn 1 DFPh.
↓ Read the rest of this entry…

└ Tags: , , ,
2 Comments

The Wars of the Roses

by on November 5, 2012 at 9:58 pm
Posted In: Books

Osprey’s title on the Wars of the Roses is typical of their Man-at-Arms line. Half the book is a good simple history of the period, and a fairly solid introduction to it. There’s no details, no sense of the people, but given the proverbial confusion that the Wars can engender, this cut-down summary seems to be a good place to start.

It is also nice in that it manages to point out a fair amount of ‘received fiction’ in the normal accounts, beginning with a paragraph-long description of the Wars, and then stating “A familiar story perhaps: but not containing a word of truth.”

It’s an early Osprey book, so the color plates are good without being great. However, the discussion of the plates is extra long, and informative.

└ Tags: , , ,
1 Comment

A37 Dreil Team

by on November 1, 2012 at 12:00 pm
Posted In: ASL

Continuing our tour of the Market-Garden scenarios, Patch and I started this one in October 2009…:

Just started the sixth scenario of the Market Garden series with Patch tonight, with me as the Brits.

It’s fairly interesting. The Brits have to exit 8 VP off the GG end of board 22 in 9 turns. The distance isn’t that great, and the British have a good amount of firepower, and are well equiped with multiple MMGs, LMGs, PIATs, and a mortar. But the stream on the board is flooded, except for the two edge hexes (which are merely deep), which limits the crossing options to four hexes, two of which are adjacent to each other.

The Germans only have six squads, two leaders and two LMGs. However, three of those squads are elite, and both leaders are 9-1s.

Oh, yeah, and they have a Panther.

Patch set up with the Pather guarding the NE (right) bridge and ford by himself, one leader, two squads and LMG on Level 2 of the one Multi-Story building in his setup area, and the rest near the other (closer) bridge.

I took a while to do my setup. I just wasn’t at all sure as to how I wanted to handle this.

The eventual plan was fairly conservative. Even with only two areas to cover, he doesn’t have enough for a great defense in depth. I figured to move out into the center area and engage the troops guarding the nearer bridge. I’d also send a unit across the W10 ford. It’s slow, but it makes sure I will get someone across. I planned on pushing a PIAT as far as I could towards the other bridge to keep him honest. That didn’t work out so well. DFF broke a LMG squad with the 8-1, and and Final Fire broke the PIAT squad in R1 (he retained rate).

Sadly, I only thought of it after I was moving, but it would have been interesting to run a squad from Y6 to the R7 bridge, and advance to Q8. Thanks to all the buildings and the range, it’s easier to do than it looks. They’d be in some trouble, but it would force some hard decisions from Patch.


Situation, British Turn 1, end of MPh.

I rallied the LMG squad with the leader during rally. Since Patch couldn’t get at the other squad, that left me in a very good position for the next turn.

Patch preped the squads in N7 at my squad in the Orchard near the bridge and rolled poorly. The LMG fired twice at S5, but couldn’t get an effect. H4h2 fired at S5, with a -1 (no cover…) and got a 2MC. Thankfully, both squads passed.

For movement, he pulled in the O10 flank, and shifted the Panther one hex so it could cover the R7 bridge.

My MTR managed three shots (ROF 2…) but couldn’t get anything at 2FP, even with the -1 Air Burst TEM. However, R6 got a 1MC on them, breaking the leader and pinning both squads.

This left Patch with quite a problem, and had to think about it quite a while. He ended up routing the leader next door and leaving the squads in place. He’d been tempted to self-break them to get them away from the MTR, but the furthest available rout target was M6. If he was going to rout, he wanted to go further.

This leaves me with a decision. I had been planning on using the MTR to put Smoke on the bridge, since I assumed the ACQ would be useless anyway. Now I need to decide if I want to try to kill the two squads, not great odds, but the best that MTR is ever likely to see….


Situation, German Turn 1, end of MPh.
↓ Read the rest of this entry…

└ Tags: , , ,
2 Comments

A36 Oy Veghel

by on October 25, 2012 at 12:00 pm
Posted In: ASL

The fifth game of Patch and I’s tour of the Market-Garden scenarios got going in September 2009…:

In our continuing series of Annual ’91 Market-Garden games, we discussed for a bit, and I decided to take the defending Americans.

Then I look at ROAR and find the Americans are the underdogs! >.< I demanded the American Balance. Not that I expect depriving him of Schuerzen to actually do much.

It’s an odd setup. The Americans start out piled in two hexes and move first. Then the Germans enter on their half of the turn.

I sent half the force east (up) through town to guard that road in, since I figured there was a good chance that Patch would send some infantry around that way behind the grain. The other half proceeded through town, behind the jeep, which dashed off to set up the 57mm ATG in 16B5.

Patch did not disappoint. Six of nine squads swung south to go around the edge of the pond on board 13. My MMG was in 10Z10, and I used it to put residual in 13Y6 (the first hex of the elevated road) the first time he moved through. Sadly, the original shot, and two Resid rolls did nothing. He parked the first PzIV in 13Y10, giving him a nice LOS down towards my position.

He did surprise me by having the StuH stay back.


Situation, both halves of turn 1.

For my second turn, I started shuffling the east force around, to cover the NE area, especially since there was now a good chance that he’d end up in that area. I should have pulled the jeep out of LOS in 16B5, but decided I’d rather keep my quick move options open. He nearly got it with a DFPh shot that did cause a PTC to strip Concealment on the crew.

The StuH also fired at 19G10, obviously preparing to fire smoke there on his Prep.


Situation, American turn 2, DFPh.
↓ Read the rest of this entry…

└ Tags: , , ,
1 Comment