Shiloh and the Western Campaign of 1862
Few books have, and need, an introduction half as long as Cunningham’s book. The editors spend a fair amount of effort explaining why an unpublished thesis from 1966 is being published in 2007. And, the main point is all too true: there have been way too few books written studying Shiloh. The other point is that Cunningham anticipated much of the revisionist takes on the battle that started in the ’90s. That’s less immediately interesting to the reader, but as someone really studying the battle and its historiography, it is a very good point.
One disturbing part of the book, which is discussed in the introduction, is a number of revisions to the original. Generally speaking, these get some very extensive footnotes, and can be enough to make you wonder just how good the book really is. However, this is a healthy sign. Normally, a book gets properly edited, which is something of a conversation between the author and the editor to improve the book by examining it for flaws and fixing them. Since Cunningham was already dead, this couldn’t happen, and the editors instead made the changes they felt were needed, and made extensive notes about it all. So instead, you are seeing a book forever stuck in the normal revision process.
As for the book itself, it is good, but not without flaws. In general, Cunningham goes into all the main actions of the Western theater of the ACW in 1862, starting with Grant’s advance up the Tennessee River, and ending with the fall of Corinth. There’s a large number of maps included. And the star of it all is the fighting of the first day of Shiloh, April 6, 1862.
The problems are varied, and generally minor in comparison, but still important. The maps are adequate, but not great. This mostly is caused by reliance on a fairly poor texture to try and show woods, which mostly clutters the maps. The text too often dissolves into lists of all the component commands of a unit (generally in an attack), giving their order from one side to the other. If you want to stop and parse that out, or refer back to the list later as the units get mentioned again, that’s fine enough, but it does not make for readable text.
Structurally, the biggest problem is running out of steam. The post-battle part (through Corinth) is not as detailed as the taking of Forts Henry and Donelson. Much more important is the entire second day feels very glossed over. Compared to the very careful laying out of detail in the first day, it seems ill-served.
On the plus side, the preliminaries to the battle are very well served. Cunningham shows just what a mess of an army Johnston was bringing to battle, and some of why some of the preparations happened as they did. I don’t think goes as much into the difficulty of the march to Shiloh as he might have have, but its certainly there. Much better, he covers the Union advance to Pittsburgh Landing in good detail, showing what kind of forward position they were dealing with. That is worth much right there, and combined with the details of the battle itself, make it a worthwhile book.

Discussion ¬